Lo, Nuns! is an anthology of stories by Jemma Topaz, presented as an accounting of the different religious orders across the fantasy realms of the Eighty Kingdoms, compiled by our eggy narrator/protagonist/chronicler.

Cover of Lo, Nuns by Jemma Topaz depicting a pseudo-illuminura of five nows and one of their wifes.

What is beneath my habit is nun of your business

It is about nuns. It is also a book about the lengths one has to go through to get proper trans healthcare, be recognized as a woman, and how to be yourself and live a life when your body is made revolutionary. It is about finding out what it means to be Sisters.

This is not a review; this is a critique. If you are expecting the former, let's get this out of the way: Lo, Nuns! has Jemma Topaz at her funniest, most sensual, most intoxicating writing. I don’t care if you are not into nuns, and I glare at you if you think it has nothing to offer you because it may be classified as erotica, with the unsaid implication this is somehow “lesser”. Prudish qualms are not valid excuses; they are keeping you from enjoying enriching, priceless literature. Be an adult reading an adult book written for adults. You will get this book, you will tear through it, and you will beg for more; you’re lucky too, for Jemma is as prolific as she is talented. If you are a good girl, I will even let you sit by my feet as you talk at length about your favorite story. 1

I rate it twelve kisses exchanged for Milk of the Saints.

Critique, unlike a review, is as much about its author as it is about the art piece that stirred the fires of creation. A critique is an artistic production of its own, even more opinionated and personal than a review. The primary purpose of art, even more primal than communication, is transformation; to experience it is to emerge a different person than you were before, embracing change by accepting or rejecting aspects of the art. As such, every piece of art is successful the moment it enacts the transformation required to lead to the creation of critique. As much as “value”8 is something that can be assigned to art, I believe that something is deemed valuable art the moment it inspires a single critique. 

So yes, if your question is just “should I read this”, the existence of this critique is by itself an answer.

Now that we understand each other, let's get through this critique, shall we?

Jemma Topaz may be one of the most versatile authors working today, and she flexes her range like a manul unburdened by its winter coat3. Yes, in Lo, Nuns! Yes, the “nun book”, which many readers may expect to be a pretty straightforward book, offers many delights for the curious and connoisseur alike.

The first story, The Saints of Faggots Lane focuses on our chronicler, for she is no mere passive framing device but a rich, flavorful character on her own. It is “eggfic”, but with an unusual flair — Jemma would never be so crass as to miss the opportunity for greatness by making it your classic egg-cracking dress go spinny story. And yet, there is sweetness, care, and sincere wholesomeness to it that no safe “cozy” tales can ever achieve. Part of the spell is the voice. Jemma perfectly captures the voice of the travelogues so popular across 17th-19th centuries, making it submit to her as she molds it into something that can serve her designs. And what a tale it is: of exploration as recognition of the self, of the transgender and divinity, of sex work and pleasure, of womanhood and lesbianism, chasseurs and criminal boons of polyamory. It is also remarkable how a voice usually associated with the most unpleasant, proto-tourist, imperial perspectives was reimagined as a connective force community-building across time and space. It also works to make our useless lesbian protagonist quite loveable, as she displays genuine interest in others rather than a voyeur’s gaze, lending her a disarming dorky charm. 

Checking The Teeth, is our first proper tale, as we follow Sister Ysult of the Aconite Order. A tale of wolves and women, about the violence done to them and Her fury. About how proper charity has teeth. As stories go, has as a proper, rich fairy-tale feeling. Familiar and strange, intriguing and the perfect appetizer for Lo, Nuns!’s delights. Sister Ysult has one hell of a presence and looms over the entire story. Exactly what you want for an opener, planting the seeds that will be explored in great depth in later stories.

In The Giantess and the Virgin, we follow Novice Enni as she joins the Order of Saint Brecher. Tasked with providing for a sacred giant, Enni discovers the meaning of holy pain, the pleasure of being crushed and smashed, as well as a grand purpose in rope burn and bondage to sisterhood — and a grander purpose within the giantesses mouth. There is a lot of that sweetness and trust that I mentioned before, setting the perfect foreplay and bringing comfort and love in submission; it erodes edges and soaks through the writing, warping it more erotic and welcoming, inviting you to imagine yourself in kinks and pleasures that you usually don't partake in. Such vivid imagery of tongues I have never read; ah, to close my eyes and let them wrap themselves around me.

The scholarly Sister Anaïs of Saints Justine would want nothing more than to dedicate herself to her study of fossils and enjoy the quiet she left her unhappy marriage for, but in Petrification, finds herself entrusted to the secret of her order: the care of a captive demon. An unlikely friendship, a delightful mirror of neurodiversity to be seen in, how fun and regretful it can be to get into a web of obligations and promises. Of self-respect even when you love a bully. This is such a sweet tale that resonates so much with us who have played both roles: that of monsters that want to be loved and of those that love women deemed monstrous. And the masterful long build-up and foreplay makes the climactic eroticism so much more powerful.

The Death of Körbl Baukenecht is another egg story. It is about Cádia, a spy who finds herself in the care of the sisters of Saint Liutgard. Again, Jemma would not waste thread when she could spin. This egg-cracking is about delivering to women what they need, no matter what they need, no matter the cost. It is about suicidal behaviour, the connection between sex work and care labor, age and beauty, about living and choices. I will not lie, this tale struggled to win me over during the first scenes, but let me tell you: it has quickly grown into, if not my emotional favorite, definitely the one I found to have the most stimulating writing. It may be the one I keep returning to; my appreciation of it only grows.

Our narrator/framing device returns in The Resting Place, sharing with us an unusual tale. When she was a journalist attached to a cursed expedition searching for the grave of a Saint, only to end up as its only survivor and find herself in transfemme Avalon. It is, however, not a tale or place about escapist fantasy and wish-fulfilment. It is about what we owe ourselves, what we owe our sisters, why we do not stealth when it is afforded to us, why we show ourselves and damn any “prime directive” nonsense. That no matter how hated, we have to show ourselves living happily. For our sisters. Oh, and also about useless lesbians that somehow still manage to get a wife.

The Hermitess is the story of Mother Pine/Sister Simone and how she came to be the ever-wandering pilgrim. It is an amusing tale, cradled by the joint caresses of a sensual horror story of vampires and lesbianism, two loves that always go great together. Trapped in a priory with strange nuns, one by one Simone’s Sisters switch teams to the beckoning red habits of the Order of Saint Sanglante. Jemma plays with tone so well through this story, and is extremely funny while playing with vampire tropes and these useless lesbians that keep coming out as gay as if it was not known by everyone; nowhere her conducting of tone is as strong as the tragic bittersweetness of turning away from happiness because in a moment of weakness you failed to recognize it. We all have been as funny and sad as Sister Simone.

Boars, Sows, and Piglets is the story of Cibele, a recent widow and Baroness-Elector, who finds herself under the protection of the order of the Saint of Red Petals. Sister Mercedes invades her mansions and mourning, and the physically and intellectually muscular nun quickly becomes her bodyguard, falling in love, and both get dragged into a tangled tale of noble intrigue and magic viciousness. I rarely buy into the bodyguard thing — how much of a useless thing you have to be that this is the girl you get, the one assigned to you — but it worked great to me because of the chemistry and powerful personalities of Mercedes and Cibele. It also helps it keeps going between tense and intense, quiet domestic moments interrupted by desperate, urgent action.

The Order of the Saints is about Mother Superior Vérene, of the order of Saint Gwenaëlle, well-known for their love of cats — creatures Mother Vérene hates and is forced to tolerate. Until cheerful, chubby Sister Miette transfers into the convent, and mischief seems to follow her around — or is it all Mother Vérene’s paranoia and projection? Clearly, there is a mischievous little kitty going around the convent, but whose habit does she wear? Jemma never forgets that sex and eroticism are supposed to be fun as well as funny, and she loves to have fun with it as much as she loves making language squirm; I always loved Jemma’s writing the most when it is at its playful, and this was certainly a story in which she delivered. The clever use of mental states and imagery marks this one as the most entertaining story in Lo, Nuns!

In Sanctuary, pirates besiege the Prioress Zoraida and her people, and she receives no succour from the world of men. Gallant Sister Valeria answers the call of heroism, turning the priory and the neighbouring locals into an impressive fighting force, strangers to lovers, boys to nuns. Valeria is so confident, stubborn, and charming, it was hard not to keep a smile engraved on my face while reading this story. 7

The Quarry returns to our werewolf nuns and Sister Ysult; a much younger and somehow even more ferocious Ysult, stumbling into the trickery and affairs of a returning watercolour sorceress. And also how a werewolf got her wife, by being extremely genre-savvy and speedrunning Umineko.

Oh Wayward Sisters follows Agnethe, a former nun who returned to the world of men, which would soon use and discard her. Running from pirate turf wars and serial killers of the law, she stumbled into nuns of feathery dark habits and darker actions dedicated to Saint Morrigna. You know what they say about strange bird-women you meet on the road and invite you into crystalline ponds. They give you the best kisses and will draft you into a war that they did not start, but they will definitely end. A tale of performative heterosexuality, violence, cruelty, but also the most intense erotic scenes in Lo, Nuns!.

So that’s Lo, Nuns!; a treat for everyone. Tender, sweet, and unapologetically transfeminine and lesbian.

And now to artistic transfiguration and my own cogitation.

Writing Your Freak, Like A Freak, For Your Freaks

We live in a world of tenuous attention, of trends and token appeasement of tastes. There may not be a more double-edged curse than the thing that you are really into something and it gets a spot in the limelight.

In one hand, you sure get a lot of what you want. In the other, you get none of what you want.

When someone says they want to read on nuns, they expect a fucking book about nuns. Most of the time they will have a pornographic nun costume, or the vibes, or a general paintbrush. Superficial, but gets the job done. For most people, it will do enough.

Replace nun with knights. Or dragons. Or mech pilots.

It will probably be popular. Hell, being superficial and having wide appeal is basically a requirement for anything to be “successful.” It is, however, incompatible with being a freak, with going deep into specifics and what makes that topic or microgenre so appealing. The freaks of those special interests will be left unsatisfied. The freak remains unfreaked. The need remains unattended.

But where does the difference lie? That is something I struggle with figuring out, so I share my humble findings.

It is all about context.

When I am writing a character and I want to know if they are a compelling character, and more importantly, if they will please the freaks that vibe with my own freak, I run her through a little test. It is something I like to call the “Coffee Shop AU Test”. If I am able to put this character, fully divorced from her context, in a coffee shop or other wildly different alternative universe, do they remain the same? If they do, they are not being properly shaped by their context. They must change when their context changes; the divorce has to leave scars. If they remain unblemished, I press delete and start again.

Sure, butch muscular lady Arthurian knight is lovely no matter what. Rotate her in your mind. Now, imagine she was the gym-rat that served as super for the building her mom owns and is here to check your plumbing and split you in two with a strap? Still hot, would probably still do it for most people. The question is, are they both, somehow, the same character? I don’t think you are fully getting the “Arthurian knight” or “chivalry” if you can have the same character be both with nothing about her changing with the drastic bending of context. 4 Even if they are different takes on the same woman, they should be two irreconcilably different persons.

Lo, Nuns! is about hitting that context with every single character in its extensive cast. About what makes a nun, and delivering it. Context feeding context. Saints beckoning Saints. These are wildly different women, but all are women. All are Sisters. And all are nuns.

This is not done through aesthetics, vibes, or lazy reliance on tropes and worn semiotics. The most powerful symbol of the hard work and dedication to the freak of this book is the nun’s habit.

Jemma wrote an entire book about nuns without once fetishizing a nun's habit, without an objectifying gaze clinging to it — and its wearers. Only the briefest of descriptions, if at all; a feather here, crimson there, a veil over a scarred face. Markers of orders, identity mapping new meaning. Goddess, I think not even half of the stories have habits mentioned at all.

And yet, as a reader you always know. There is no doubt in you, ever, that these women are nuns.

The book does not suffer in any way from lack of purple, lengthy, nun-vibes descriptions; if anything, it is the opposite. Lo, Nuns! uses a combination of careful language and your imagination to craft a more sensual and aesthetically pleasing version of the women and their habits than anything you could get from a drooling, protracted, description. Well, probably. We will never know because Lo, Nuns! spoils us with lobster too buttery and thighs too thick. The books’ illustrator has graced Lo, Nuns! with what may be the most striking cover in the entirety of transbian literature; if there is a flaw in Anemone’s masterwork strokes and sense of colour is that zir depiction of the nuns is going to break into your mind and demand rent because ze now owns your nunagination. Jemma’s writing may be brilliant at stating just enough to demand a workout from your imagination, but some images are just too powerful not to linger.

Erotica is When You Can Get Into This Shit No Matter What

Lo, Nuns!, like most of Jemma’s work, is extremely sensual and erotic. It is also all about quantity and quality. I have written more lengthy and numerous sex scenes on average per book, and it is never what people remember or the labels I get attached to them; yet, the eroticism casts a thick haze over every single story. It does not, however, rely on any pornographic imagery or techniques.

Hold on, how can I even say something like this? Where does the distinction between pornographic and erotic lie? Well, it is mostly a thing you know when you see it, right? I found, unfortunately, that this attitude ends up being used to dismiss what you don’t like as pornographic, but what you like, as erotic. We will not get any useful framework of analysis by buying into that premise.

It is all about senses, and whose senses you are experiencing the art through. Pornographic works directly on you; it works with what you are bringing. You came in here thinking this stimulates your senses and desires; there is no need to sell it to you. You're already into this. So the entire focus of pornographic techniques on art is delivering satisfaction on that front.

Erotica, however, is about the feelings and senses of the characters. It is putting the work there, and honestly, cares little about what you are bringing to the reading. You are in here for a ride, but this is not about you. Erotica will satisfy you, and if properly applied, its techniques will get you desire and feel like the characters.

Lo, Nuns! was such a delightful example of this. I fell in love with all these women, got deeply familiar with their sense of self and the world, with what intrigues and repulses them. The most impactful and arousing scenes were those involving things I am not remotely into; it did not matter; they were into, and I was fully in tune with their wants and desires. My own senses and feelings were conquered and sublimated into the character’s. That is the victory of erotic techniques, and Jemma’s writing is due a triumph. 5

Now, is the distinction even worth making?

Not at all? Maybe? Crucial?

For a reader? Probably not. For a critic, heh, who knows. For an author? Definitely. After all, they are two schools of techniques with different goals and approaches. You want more quivers in your arrows6, so you probably want to familiarize yourself with both. And understanding the strengths of your arsenal and how to use them effectively? Isn’t that what being a skilled writer is all about?

Final Musings

I absolutely abhor longplum, but can we please make girlplum a thing?

Farewell, dearest reader; until writing’s fancies accouple us.

—Your ever-unfaithful Lizzie.

1  Would you not like to know what I will do if you are a bad girl.

2  In the only useful meaning of the word.

3  It is terrifying; don’t look up pictures of them.

4  For example, the absolute lack of cuckoldry.

5  I may be available to ride in the chariot whispering in her ear, but it won’t be “Memento Mori” that I will be whispering.

6  Not an archer.

7  It has absolutely nothing to do with the Choice of the illustrator to give Valeria that wonderful, perfect, aquiline, monument to womanhood of a nose. Shuuuut upppp.

8  In the only useful meaning of the word.